What to check before buying a niche site
Ask for access, not a screenshot. This is the list I would run before paying a seller. It is not a valuation, and it is not a product I sell.
Ask for access, not a crop
A traffic screenshot is the seller's crop. You want a restricted user on Google Search Console, and the affiliate report (or an export) for the same months. If a seller will not add you for a few days, you do not know what you are buying. Walk, or price that uncertainty yourself. I do not price sites.
While you have access, do not change anything. No plugin updates, no indexing requests, no theme edits. You do not own it yet.
Traffic
In Performance, set the search type to Web and the range to 16 months.
- Find the bend, if there is one. A site that fell six months ago and has been flat since is a different purchase from a site that is still falling. How to read that bend is in why affiliate traffic drops.
- Open Pages and sort by clicks. If one or two URLs produce almost all of the clicks, you are buying those URLs. Read them. Ask what happens if that query gets answered on the result page without a click.
- Open Queries. Separate the site's own brand from queries a stranger would type. Branded traffic does not transfer cleanly to a new owner, and it is not the same asset as rankings for the topic.
- Compare the latest 28 days with the 28 days before them, and the latest three months with the three months before that. Averages hide a cliff at the right edge of the chart.
- Check the country. Traffic from countries your offer does not serve is smaller than the click total.
Analytics, if they offer it, is a supplement. It mixes channels. Search Console is the search asset.
Indexation
A site can show a third-party traffic estimate while the pages that earn the clicks are not indexed. The estimate is not the purchase.
- Open Indexing, then Pages. Note how many URLs are indexed, and the largest reasons the rest are not.
- Inspect the URLs that earn the clicks. You want them indexed, with a recent last crawl, and with Google's canonical matching the URL you think you are buying.
- Spot-check pages that are supposed to support those URLs. A library of "Crawled, currently not indexed" is not bonus content. It is work, or it is risk.
- Open Security and Manual Actions. This takes a minute. A manual action is the seller's problem becoming yours on the day the domain moves.
- Open robots.txt and view the source of one money page. Confirm you do not see a sitewide noindex.
How to read the status lines, including the ones that flip on a never-crawled URL, is in how to check if Google indexed a page.
Revenue
Put the affiliate report next to the Search Console months. Use the same window.
- If commissions fell and clicks did not, you may be looking at a program change, a lower rate, or a tracking break. An SEO project does not repair that.
- Ask which programs the income comes from, whether approval is tied to the seller, and whether you can be approved yourself. Links on the page are not the same thing as being paid for them.
- Ask what is missing from the chart: an email list you are not getting, coupon traffic, a social account, a private deal. If the revenue needs a channel that is not in the sale, subtract it.
- Do not treat one strong month as the run rate. Use the dull months too.
The pages
Read the pages that earn the clicks, and a sample of the rest. You are checking whether you can live with the method.
- Are the pages useful to a person who cares about the topic, or are they a thin wrapper around affiliate links? Thin pages of that kind are what Google's spam policies describe, and they are a poor thing to inherit. I will not build that kind of site, and I would not pay a premium for one.
- Articles that target the same query compete with each other. Count the overlaps. Consolidation is real work after you buy.
- Who owns the images and the text? Unlicensed photos or scraped copy are a liability, not a content library.
- Ask what was generated and whether anyone reviewed it. Unreviewed pages are not a shortcut you should pay extra for.
Ownership and the handover
- The domain is registered somewhere you can transfer. It is not a subdomain of another brand the seller is keeping.
- You know which email owns the registrar, the host, Search Console, analytics, and each affiliate program, and each of those can be moved.
- No canonical tags point at a domain you are not buying.
- Open the Links report in Search Console. You are looking for a pattern, not a score. A large set of identical anchors, from sites with no relation to the topic, is a risk. You would own that pattern the day the domain transfers. You do not need a paid backlink tool for this first look.
After you own it
If the clicks are already down, the list above tells you the shape of the problem. It does not produce the fix list.
I do that as a diagnosis on a site you own: $395, one site, up to 50 pages, from your Search Console data, with the first five fixes in priority order. I do not sell a separate pre-purchase check, and I do not value sites. If you already bought it and the chart is why you are here, start with the diagnosis. Questions go to hello@five30am.com.
More guides: Why did my affiliate site traffic drop? ยท How to check if Google indexed your pages